We know that the most common use for the roaster oven is to cook the Thanksgiving turkey, but as a type of slow cooker, you can use it for so much more than just poultry. It’s great for roasting vegetables, slow-cooking meats and you can even bake bread in some of them!
Whether you’re replacing an old unit or this is your first time purchasing one, our guide makes it easy for you to compare the best roaster oven models side by side.
There are many things to consider as you shop for one, so allow our expert tips to guide you toward the right one for your roasting and cooking needs.
Top 10 Roaster Ovens Table
|1. Rival RO180 18-Quart Roaster Oven, White||18-quart||$$||4.6|
|2. Oster CKSTRS23-SB 22-Quart Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid||22-quart||$$||4.5|
|3. Nesco 481825PR 18 Qt Professional Stainless Steel Roaster Oven with Porcelain Cookwell||6-quart||$$||4.4|
|4. Oster CKSTROSMK18 Smoker Roaster Oven, 16-Quart||16-quart||$$||4.4|
|5. Nesco 4818-14 Classic Roaster Oven, 18qt, Porcelain Cookwell||18-quart||$||4.3|
|6. Proctor Silex 32230A Stainless Steel Roaster Oven, 22-Quart||22-quart||$$||4.3|
|7. Cuisinart MSC-800 Cook Central 4-in-1 Multi-Cooker, 7 quart||7-quart||$$$$||4.2|
|8. Oster CKSTRS71 18-Quart Roaster Oven with Buffet Server, White||18-quart||$$||4.1|
|9. Nesco American Harvest 4816-25-30 Non-Stick 6-Quart Roaster Oven||6-quart||$||4.1|
|10. Nesco 4816-14G-30 6-Quart Roaster Oven with Glass Lid, Non-Stick Cookwell, Ivory||6-quart||$$$||4.0|
A Quick Note Before We Begin
Keep in mind that all of the units we listed are electric roaster ovens, which are quite different from rotisserie ovens and roasters that you place directly in your main oven.
An electric roaster oven can be used to cook more than just turkey and poultry, functioning as a spare “mini” oven in your kitchen when the main oven is occupied.
Tips to Help You Choose the Right Roaster Oven
When you make yourself a checklist of the features that are most important to you, it will be much easier for you to determine which is the best roaster oven for your needs.
- Volume. Many shoppers think that bigger is better, but the size of the roaster oven you choose really depends on the amount of food you usually prepare.
If you plan to use it to prepare a turkey or other meats only for special occasions, then make sure the typical size you purchase can fit in the roaster. Each roaster will state the maximum capacity, which isn’t a strict number but should give you an idea.
Choose the size that will be most useful to you when you need it rather than opting for the largest one. These appliances do take up quite a bit of space!
- Lid. Check out the lid of the roaster oven. Is it made of glass or stainless steel?
We really can’t say that one is better than the other, but the main difference is that you can see the contents of a glass-top roaster oven without having to remove it. We find it to be the most convenient option, but not necessarily the best one.
- Minimum Temperature. Many roaster ovens can reach temperatures of 400° F or greater, but the minimum temperature, on the other hand, varies from model to model.
Some have a simple “minimum” setting like number 2 that is below 150° F, while others only go down to a minimum of 200°F.
Top 3 Best Roaster Oven Reviews
Rival’s roaster oven beat out the competition thanks to its affordability, size, temperature range and overall quality.
It will easily fit an 18-pound turkey inside and goes down as low as 150° F when you want to keep food warm without cooking it further. What is also handy is that it lists the temperature in Celsius on the dial, as well, making it easy to use no matter what measurement system your recipe book says.
Consider this a large slow cooker that can handle just about anything you put in it.
While we did find the cord to be unreasonably short, we wouldn’t eliminate it from first place because of this. Either you have an outlet close by, or you get a small extension cord to solve the issue. We would have also appreciated an indicator light that lets you know when it is on, but then again, if you see that the knob is not pointing to the “off” position, you still know that it is “on.”
It was, without a doubt, one of the best roaster ovens we tried out of all 10!
Oster didn’t quite make it to first place, but it is one of the most popular units on our list and certainly one that we would recommend buying.
Those of you who plan to cook bigger birds or larger portions of food might appreciate this model since it can accommodate up to a 26-pound turkey.
The one main problem that this unit seems to have is regarding the temperature accuracy. The readings seemed to jump around a lot (when we measured the internal temperature), so while it does do a good job of cooking, you might need to add on some extra time or else turn the temperature up a bit from where you would normally set it.
It is just as versatile as the Rival, and it is very easy to clean. Be careful when removing the metal rack or setting hard objects in it because the surface is scratch-prone.
Not everyone requires a large, hefty roaster oven for his or her cooking needs. The 6-quart Nesco model has more than enough room for you to cook small chickens, stews, and other slow cooker meals.
In addition to roasting, it can also bake, cook and steam, making it a versatile and energy-efficient friend in the kitchen.
We noticed that the temperature range was a bit different than some of the other models, with a low of 175° F and a high of 425° F. They also recommend preheating the unit for 20 minutes before you add any food in it.
Another thing we liked about it is how they printed the temperatures on the body of the unit along with words that help you understand where to set it if you want to slow-cook, cook, roast, bake, or steam your food.
Having tried the older models of the Nesco roaster ovens, we could see that the overall quality and construction just isn’t what it used to be, but for the modern cook looking for an extra “oven” to have around that doesn’t take up much space, it gets the job done!